The Sefer is written by the great Talmid Chachem, Rav Shlomo Aviner Shlita and is titled "Uhloi Naaleh" meaning, "we will go up" to Israel.
This title was chosen since the Satmar Rav had paskened that Jews are not allowed to make Aliyah, parroting the words of Dasan Ve'aviram that said "Lo Na'aleh".....
If you remember, in Parshas Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu had sent messengers to Dasan Ve'Aviram , two agitators that were backing Korach in the machlokas, to ask them to come to him to talk peace, they answered "Lo Naaleh" ...Rashi writes that those words uttered, was an unwitting prophecy and they never did go up!
The book takes apart the entire Satmar Ideology line by line in a very respectful manner. It totally crushes every single point of the book written by R' Yoel Teitelbaum's in 1967 called "Al Hagilah Ve'al Hatmurah."
And destroys every single point in the entire series of books called Va"Yoel Moshe!
The Satmar Rav panicked in 1967, when the
IDF totally destroyed their Arab enemies with the help of Hashem! He believed that his flock would see with their own eyes the miracles that Hashem performed for the Zionists, and would want answers immediately, and so he quickly published his book called "Al Hagula", attempting to contain the damage to his SHIT'ah!
The Satmar "shvanztes" who are by in large a bunch of amai ratzim .... then accepted the moronic idea that the Satan helped the IDF!
Crazy and bizarre ....but true!
Read the following and see how Israel was surrounded by Arab wolves and totally destroyed them all!
On the eve of the war, Egypt massed approximately 100,000 of its 160,000 troops in the Sinai, including all of its seven divisions (four infantry, two armoured and one mechanized), four independent infantry brigades and four independent armoured brigades. No fewer than a third of them were veterans of Egypt's continuing intervention into the North Yemen Civil War and another third were reservists. These forces had 950 tanks, 1,100 APCs, and more than 1,000 artillery pieces.[47]
Syria's army had a total strength of 75,000 and was deployed along the Syrian border.[48]
The Jordanian Armed Forces included 11 brigades, totalling 55,000 troops[49] and equipped with some 300 modern Western tanks, 250 of which were U.S. M48 Pattons. Nine brigades (45,000 troops, 270 tanks, 200 artillery pieces) were deployed in the West Bank, including the elite armoured 40th, and two in the Jordan Valley.
100 Iraqi tanks and an infantry division were readied near the Jordanian border. Two squadrons of fighter-aircraft, Hawker Hunters and MiG 21s, were rebased adjacent to the Jordanian border.[50]
The Arab air forces were aided by volunteer pilots from the Pakistan Air Force acting in independent capacity, and by some aircraft from Libya, Algeria, Morocco, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia to make up for the massive losses suffered on the first day of the war. PAF pilots shot down several Israeli planes.[3]
The Rebbe in that book claimed that the 1967 victory was not a miracle at all, but the hand of what he called the "Sitra Achra" the Satan...
The Bais Yisroel, the Holy Gerer Rebbe laughed at that time and said "how can someone say that "G-D murdered 6 million Jews," yet when it came to save Jews, that same person says it is the " Sitra Achra?" Makes absolutely no sense!"
This Holy Sefer is in Hebrew and I will over the course of time, quote and translate pertinent excerpts from this Sefer!
The Sefer is distributed by Sefriyat Chava in Beit-EL and can be bought in Seforim Stores that carry pro-Zionist Sefarim!
For those who cannot understand Hebrew there is an English Sefer that also answers all the anti-Zionist propaganda....called "A Question of Redemption" by R' Ta'akov Moshe Bergman and is distributed by Moshe Lichtman of Kol Mevaser,in Beit Shemesh
18 comments:
De-bunk shmunk and punk
You won't understand it because you're a ignorant bum but ask someone to explain it to you, this week's Or Hachaim on the passuk VEASCHEM EZORA BAGOYIM where he explains very clearly the gamara in Kesubois that Satmar censored..... and inserted something about 3 Shevuos and yes this entity called Zionism and their atheistic regime is the cause of all problems related to Jews and they will have the same mapole as all soinei Hashem
Thousands of aviners and mad dogs like kook kakale with his mentor th can say or write whatever it won't help them ONE WORD OF THE OR HACHAIM AND CHAZAL IS MORE RELEVANT THAN ALL OF THEM
And i forgot to add that of course you won't publish my comment as usual when you're stuck and have nothing to respond, although it's irrelevant if you do or don't
"Aloi Naaleh" was said by the Maapilim who defied the Gezeirah of Golus and Moshe Rabbeinu's admonitions to accept the decree and stay in the Midbor for 40 years. They were massacred by the Emorim. Incidentally the Zionists who tried smuggling DP Holocaust survivors into Palestine defying the ruling British also called themselves Maapilim.
In 1968 Harav hagaon reb. Menachem Kasher (a Gerrer chasid) in his 300 page SEFER "HATKUFAH HAGDOLA" totaly debunks and destroys those two vile anti Israel propaganda manifestos.
it's an amazing SEFER that every right thinking Jew should have in his house,it is an antidote to the vicious and poisonous antisemitic propaganda that has unfortunately poisoned the minds of tens of thousands of innocent jews with a pathological and abnormal hatred to our God given holy land of Eretz Yisroel.
CHAIM.
The Vayoel Moshe with the 3 Oaths was refuted by the Avnei Nezer in his responsa 412 & 416 saying that we cannot deduce Halacha from Agadah & the 3 Oaths are interdependent on each other since the nations violated the oath of subjugating the Jewish Nation the oath is no longer valid. Even the great Kanoi the Minchas Elazar never evoked the 3 oaths. His approach was to separate yourself from the secular Jews.
Nevertheless congratulations to Rav Aviner.
Congratulations to Rav Mendel Kasher for The Hatekufa HaGedolah published right after the 6 Day War.
Burning the candle from both ends is mind boggling.
The Satmar Rav in his Al HaGeulah val HaTemurah writes that the 6 Day War is not a miracle but the works of The Satan. Subsequently he writes that naturally The Zionist had to win since they had superior weapons, launched a surprise attack & the Arabs remained barefoot.
The fact that we were outnumbered 20 to 1 is immaterial.
This is what happens when a person is totally agenda driven.
The Satmar Rav has a right to say these things.
The overall question is how do you get away with this?
What is remarkable this is welcomed in the Charedi Yeshiva World with gushing adulation?
To Anonymous at 12:45
Learn again the Ohr Hachayim. He states explicitly that the posek is talking about Churban Bais Rishon ONLY.
Even if the Orach Hachayim did say that ...(he didn't..you am haaretz)
he soif kol soif made Aliyah "olah naaleh" ...
The truth is that .... we really didn't need a sefer debunking the Satmar books, since anyone with eyes and brains half way tied behind their backs can see reality ... we have a State B"H that has over 6, million Jews living there with over 50,000 boys learning Torah ...
and its as if you go outside and see the sun shining brightly, and an old Romanian comes by and says it's night ...
but there is a new generation now that believes that old man that tells them its night!
Your comparison to the mapilim is absurd. They went against an open, direct clear gezeira which came especiaaly because they refused to enter the land only days before.They were indeed massacred, whereas the State of Israel 2,000 years later lives and grows. If you're hinting that the Zionists shouldn't have defied the British blockade, then you're a certified psychopath.
mapeelim is fine look at what Reb Tzodok Hacohen wrote. "Moshe Rabbeinu said that the Mapeelim won't work that was THEN. But there will be a time that it would work and that is our time" Reb Tzodoks words verbatim.
Reb Tzodok in tzidkas hatzadik (I think 46)
http://www.seforimhouse.com/pages/books/6443/yoel-kahn/maaneh-chochom-byishuv-divrei-bal-vyoel-moshe-val-hageula-val-hatmurah-vdin-udvorim-bshitoso
Obviously you have no clue whatsoever about the Minchas Elozor, actually the approach of the Minchas Elozor and even the belzer ruv were much more sharp and outspoken of the ME, but someone who changes his ideology is definitely not a gadol hador and trustworthy daas Torah, a real gadol does not make mistakes in hashkafa and Mendel Treifa did change his own hashkafa, but to be honest this college graduate Mr aviner must really be a gadol hador after receiving the endorsement of a noief like you
3:38
you upgressiner naar! "someone who changes his ideology is definitely not a gadol hador and trustworthy daas Torah"
who said that? you???????
Didn't the Tanaim in the gemarrah change their minds? you farikta briah!
Go crawl back in your hole ...the virgins are coming very soon to get you!;)
3:38
Hey Minchas Elozer expert.......didn't the Minchas Elozer's only son-in-law turn into a Zionist? haa ha
Funny isn't it how G-D has a sense of humor! ha ha
Sammy... The satmar r never said this ... He said the 6 day war was a great sucess like the ramban says on chanukah. . Sam... You never reqd a book in your life, only alonim you find in your shule..
7:27
We don't need the Satmar Rebbe to tell us that it was a success.... a blind man could see that!
but he did blabber that it wasn't a miracle but that the Satan helped them achieve this success ....
A crazier bizarre statement was never uttered since the world was created!
Post a Comment