DUS IZ NIES

“I don’t speak because I have the power to speak; I speak because I don’t have the power to remain silent.” Rav Kook z"l

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Why Didn’t They Leave?

 


by David Begoun

A lesson from Yad Vashem, a grandmother and a frog about the dangers we don’t recognize until it’s too late

By now, you probably know that I’m not a big fan of Holocaust museums. I’ve written before about my discomfort with the way Jewish history and identity can so often become defined by our suffering, our persecution, and the six million Jews who were murdered, rather than by our extraordinary contributions to civilization over thousands of years.

But Yad Vashem is different.

I’ve visited Jerusalem’s Holocaust museum more times than I can count, often as a tour guide, and somehow I always come away having learned something new. Sometimes it’s a story, sometimes a photograph, sometimes a detail about the Holocaust that I hadn’t appreciated before. And recently, while guiding a group through the museum, I shared something I’d only recently learned about the building itself, something that has been on my mind ever since.

The Next Room

Yad Vashem’s Holocaust History Museum was designed by the internationally renowned Israeli architect Moshe Safdie. It’s an extraordinary structure, a long triangular prism cutting straight through the mountainside, with natural light pouring in from above.

What really fascinates me is the way Safdie designed the galleries.

As you walk through the museum, you’re forced to move from one gallery to another, following the chronological progression of the Holocaust. The galleries are deliberately concealed from view until you reach them. You cannot simply look ahead and see where the story is going.

And I think that’s absolutely brilliant.

Because one of the questions people invariably ask me when I’m guiding them through Yad Vashem is: Why didn’t the Jews leave when things started getting bad?

Why didn’t they get out of Germany when Hitler came to power? Why didn’t they recognize the danger when the Nazis began passing anti-Jewish laws? Why did so many remain as the situation grew progressively worse, until eventually it was too late?

It’s a perfectly understandable question. Standing in the museum today, knowing what we know, it seems almost inconceivable that anyone would have stayed. And that’s precisely the question Safdie’s architecture is designed to help answer.

By preventing us from seeing the next gallery, Safdie places us, at least for a moment, in the position of the people who actually lived through those years. They couldn’t see what was coming next either. They had no idea how much worse it would get or what horrors awaited them around the corner.

Today, we walk into Yad Vashem knowing how the story ends. We know about the ghettos and the cattle cars, about Auschwitz and Treblinka, and the gas chambers and the crematoria.

But imagine being a Jew living in Berlin in 1933.

Hitler has just come to power. There are ugly speeches, hateful posters, boycotts of Jewish businesses. Jewish civil servants are losing their jobs. It’s frightening, certainly. But this is Germany. Your country. Your home. The place where your parents and grandparents lived, where you built your business, raised your children, and made your life.

Surely this madness won’t last. Surely this is as bad as it will get.

Then come the Nuremberg Laws in 1935, stripping Jews of their citizenship rights. More restrictions. More humiliations. More reasons to worry. But life goes on. People still get married, children go to school, and families still gather around the Shabbat table. Perhaps things will improve after the next election, the next change in government, the next international crisis.

And then comes November 1938. Kristallnacht. Synagogues are burned, Jewish businesses are smashed, and thousands of Jewish men are arrested and sent to concentration camps.

Suddenly, the danger is impossible to ignore.

But now, leaving is no simple matter. Where do you go? Who will take you? How do you get a visa? What happens to your business, your home, your elderly parents?

Many German Jews understood the danger and desperately tried to escape. Hundreds of thousands succeeded. Others found the doors of the world closing in their faces. And then, in 1939, war breaks out. Soon, for many, the opportunity to escape is gone altogether.

That’s the terrible genius of Safdie’s architecture. It helps answer the question that seems so obvious to us today, but was anything but obvious to those living through it.

Because when you’re standing in one room, you cannot see the next.

"Lakewood is not Yerushlayim" Why Aren't American Rabbis Telling Jews to Come Home?

 

Left-wing activist Arik Ascherman fined ILS 60,000 for harassing family

 

Arik Ascherman

The Jerusalem Magistrate's Court ordered left-wing activist Arik Ascherman, who heads the organization Torat Tzedek, to pay a total of NIS 60,000 in damages and legal costs to a Jewish family from Kokhav Hashahar after he filmed them during an outing in an open area and accused them of trespassing and breaking the law.

In her ruling, Judge Tali Lahav found that the allegations Ascherman published had not been substantiated and that the publication was defamatory, degrading and humiliating.

The lawsuit was filed on the family's behalf by attorney Menashe Yado of the Honenu organization following an incident in 2024 near Nahal Yitav. Six family members, parents and their children, were on an outing there when Ascherman filmed them and accused them of misconduct.

Ascherman accused the family members of "violating the Torah," "trespassing on land" and "trampling on the law and setting a poor example for their children." The incident was filmed and broadcast live on Ascherman's Facebook page, revealing the faces of the family's minor children.

The lawsuit alleged that the publication violated the family members' privacy and damaged their reputations, and that exposing the minors' identities violated the law.

In her ruling, Judge Lahav examined Ascherman's allegations against the family, particularly his claim that they had trespassed on land. She found that this allegation had not been substantiated, pointing to the nature of the area where the outing took place.

The ruling stated, "The family members are seen in the publication walking through an open area that is neither fenced nor cultivated. This publication, which attributes criminal conduct to an ordinary family, requires a clear distinction between invoking the defenses of good faith and 'I spoke the truth' and publishing, without thorough examination, footage of a family outing that is being portrayed as deliberate trespassing on land."

The court also addressed Ascherman's own testimony, which indicated that he had published the allegations before completing a factual inquiry into the trespassing claim.

The ruling emphasized that even someone who sees himself as working to expose offenses or prevent moral wrongdoing must act responsibly toward those against whom he publishes allegations. The judge ruled, "The defendant's role, as he described it, of documenting violations of the law and even theft in the moral sense, also creates a moral and social obligation not to publicly disgrace someone who has done nothing disgraceful."

The court upheld the family's claims of defamation and invasion of privacy and ordered Ascherman to pay them a total of NIS 60,000, including legal costs.

Attorney Menashe Yado, who represented the family, said, "For years, Ascherman has harmed the people of Israel and the foundations of the Torah while publishing such allegations against other people. Ascherman is a quarrelsome and contentious man who attacked and harassed an innocent family without any justification. I welcome the court's just ruling."

Several months earlier, Ascherman was indicted in a separate case over allegations that he assaulted a Jewish shepherd.

Bereaved Sister: 'Anger is not enough'

 

Hallel Granot-Gruner, sister of fallen soldier Amitay Granot, describes her pain over Charedi refusal to enlist and the moment she realized that anger alone would not bring a solution.


Hillel Granot Gruner, whose brother Capt. Amitay Granot was killed fighting Hezbollah, shouted at Charedi protesters chanting, "We would rather die than enlist," telling them, "My brother really did die for you! How are you not ashamed?"

In her new book, "The Most Immediate Need,"  co-written with Shvut Raanan and published by Yedioth Books, she revisits the moment when the anger she had accumulated over nearly two years of campaigning for Charedi enlistment erupted, and the realization that led her to change direction.

"The physical presence of the people standing right before my eyes also intensified the anger and frustration they stirred in me," she writes at the beginning of the book. "I couldn't stay silent. I stuck my head out of the car window and shouted: 'My brother really did die for you! How are you not ashamed?!' I wanted to get out of the car and shout some more, but we had already driven away."

That evening, she recounts, she regretted not having managed to express the full extent of her pain.
 "I regretted not being able to express more clearly the frustration, anger, hurt, and feelings of betrayal and loneliness that overwhelmed me at that moment, when my brothers, my own people, were demonstrating before me that they would rather die than answer the cry of their brothers' blood calling out to them".

Yet it was precisely this charged encounter that led her to an unexpected conclusion. "In that small, tangible moment, which brought all those difficult emotions to the surface, I realized I was heading in the wrong direction," she writes.

To explain the depth of her pain, Granot Gruner returns to the morning of the October 7th massacre and d the moment when the sense of security she had known until then began to unravel.

"At 8:20, I was sitting at the table with my grandfather, drinking coffee and completely ignoring the siren sounding in the background. It simply seemed like a mistake - why would there suddenly be a siren? A full hour passed before we began to understand the scale of what was happening."

At the end of that day, she recounts, she looked at her children and realized that the world she had known had changed.

"I looked at my children, gripped by terror at the knowledge that the sense of security I had felt could no longer protect me. In my heart, I promised them I would do everything to protect them and ensure they grew up in a safe and prosperous country."

Alongside the terror, she also describes the sense of mutual responsibility she felt as so many Israelis mobilized to rescue others.

"I saw how they came to the Gaza border communities, in uniform or civilian clothes, with a rifle, a handgun or a broken beer bottle, with a tank, with their little car or with their contacts at the news channels. I am surrounded by an extraordinary people of heroes who will not hesitate for a moment and will come immediately, whatever the danger." 

But eight days after the war began, tragedy struck her family as well.

"The second part of the war began for me just a week and a day later, on Sunday at five in the afternoon. The casualty notification officers knocked on the door and told us that Amitay, my brother, had been killed fighting Hezbollah."

The seven-day mourning period, she recounts, was filled with immense pain, but also with a sense of being embraced by Israeli society.

"People from every part of our society came with food and help, or simply a desire to listen and show that they were there." 

As the war continued, alongside that sense of mutual responsibility, Granot Gruner increasingly felt that the burden was being shared unfairly.

In her book, she describes the heavy toll paid by civilians, soldiers and their families: residents waiting to be rescued, hostages held in captivity, families displaced from their homes, and people with physical and psychological injuries who needed help.

She focuses particularly on reservists, who were repeatedly called up for extended service while their families, jobs and personal lives were left behind. 

"Round after round, they were called on to help, pleading for more people to help shoulder the burden and for more combat soldiers to relieve them at their posts, but they were met with silence."

She later asks, 

"How much longer can these people with families, business owners, students, teachers, doctors or high-tech workers put their lives on hold for the war? How much more harm will be done to their children, their partners, the mothers and fathers who cannot sleep at night?"

She says it was precisely the understanding that there was no choice but to keep fighting that made the need to broaden the ranks of those serving more urgent.


"We needed help, more people to join us and enlist." 

Against this backdrop, she describes the hurt she felt at Charedi demonstrations against enlistment, and later at remarks by former Sephardic Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef, who declared that if Charedim were forced to enlist, they would leave the country. "Our brothers, whom we called on for help in a time of trouble, turned their backs on us," she writes.

Granot Gruner stresses that her anger does not stem from any prior estrangement from Charedi society. On the contrary, she describes a deep emotional connection built over many years.

"My relationship with haredi society did not begin with that encounter at the demonstration. I have loved this community for many years. The music, the culture, the simplicity and kindness, the allure I feel in its connection to the past, in holding fast to its roots."

 But since the war began, she says, that connection has fractured.

"My anger at their refusal to enlist, from the very first months of the war, distanced me from that connection." For nearly two years, she campaigned for Charedi enlistment through media appearances, participation in rallies and cooperation with organizations representing those serving in the military.

But the encounter with the protesters during Hanukkah, which stirred particularly difficult emotions, prompted her to reassess not only her attitude toward Charedi society but also the way she had tried to bring about change.

"I realized that even if I went back to that demonstration, even if I shouted to the heavens, even if I kept writing and protesting and being angry at the Charedim and the government and everyone who continues to ignore the problem or justify it, the problem would not be solved,"
 she writes.

She says the anger and accusations, however justified she believes them to be, prevent her from identifying the root of the crisis. 

"It will not be solved because the anger, frustration and accusations prevent me from seeing the true root of the problem, and when we cannot see the root, when we do not understand the foundation of it all, it does not matter how right we are or how angry-the problem remains unresolved."

That realization gave rise to her book, which examines the relationship between the state and Charedi society and the possibility of finding a solution that addresses the crisis at its roots.

"I began writing this book with the understanding that we were heading in the wrong direction," Granot Gruner explains. "I am part of the struggle against conduct that endangers the country's future, but I have not been able to put forward a proposal for a fundamental solution that gets to the root of the problem and outlines a conceptual model to help us reach a solution."

 She says she decided to set aside her anger and try to gain a deeper understanding of the relationship between the state and Charedi society, seeking to outline a conceptual and practical model that would account for the complexity of the situation.

Thus, out of personal bereavement, a sense of betrayal and the painful encounter with anti-enlistment protesters, Granot Gruner embarked on a journey aimed not merely at voicing protest, but at trying to find another way to address one of Israeli society's most complex crises.

Song of Bechoros

 


Mamdani/Satmar doubles down on tone-deaf Oct. 7 post attacking Israel for ‘ongoing genocide’

 

Mayor Zohran Mamdani appeared flustered when asked about his Israel-bashing Oct. 7 anniversary post during an onstage interview Wednesday, before doubling down on his tone-deaf remarks accusing the Jewish State of an “ongoing genocide.”

Mamdani was asked about his statement marking the third anniversary of Hamas’ deadly invasion of Israel – in which he spent less than a quarter of its time mourning the 1,100 victims of the vicious 2023 terrorist attack and was quickly condemned – during an interview with reporter Andrew Ross Sorkin at the New York Times’ DealBook conference.

“The suffering did not begin nor end that day. It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza,” Mamdani had said, citing Hamas statistics as he decried the Palestinian casualties of the war launched in response to the terrorist attack.

Sorkin noted that many Jewish leaders said the twisted statement made Jewish New Yorkers less safe. He asked if he felt “an extra sort of responsibility” around the language he used – in light of the growing number of hate crimes against Jewish New Yorkers. 

Mamdani shot back, telling the journalist that his story “doesn’t cover the entirety of the day,” and attempted to tout his concern for New York’s large Jewish population.

The mayor brought up his presence at a memorial for the victims of Hamas’ terrorist attack – where he was viciously booed by anti-Israel protesters – before giving a word salad response.

“And I say this to say that my politics is one that believes that there has to be room to mourn everyone,” He said in his own defense, adding he was proud to be mayor of the most Jewish city in the country. 

Sorkin then asked Mamdani if it would have been more appropriate to have made a statement on Oct. 7 condemning the terror attack, then waiting until Oct. 8 to condemn Israel – a question met with appeals by the conference’s attendees. 

The Satmarer  turned red after the question was posed and stumbled through his response, before alleging that the terror attack had been used “as a justification for all that followed it.”

“When the Israeli government is conducting a genocide of Palestinians, oftentimes the defense that will be given, no matter what day that it’s asked about, will be the relationship to October 7,” he said. 

When Sorkin pushed the mayor, asking him if he understood why others might object to how he remembered the day, he managed to bring the conversation back to the topic of Palestinians. 

“Whenever I’m asked about why do you support Palestinian freedom or Palestinian rights, I speak about the importance of extending these same values to everyone,” the Satmarer said. 

“And that is who I am. That’s who I’ll always be.”

Mamdani’s slanted statement had been quickly met with blowback last month.

“What he is trying to do is hijack the only day we have for the victims and survivors. He’s trying to hijack the day to talk about attacking Israel,” Israeli UN Ambassador Danny Danon told The Post. “It’s like on 9/11 you talked about victims and al-Qaeda terrorists.”

“It’s basically taking the only day we have for victims and trying to attack Israel with propaganda,” Danon said.

Denmark’s oldest-ever person, 112, outed as one-time ‘prominent’ Nazi

 

Denmark’s oldest-ever person has been outed as a former local leader of her country’s Nazi party.

Kirsten Schwalbe was widely celebrated last month when she became the oldest Dane ever, at 112 years and 218 days, after already being part of the “world’s oldest siblings” with her 104-year-old younger brother Bertel.

She initially denied ever having Nazi sympathies despite records showing she joined Denmark’s branch, the Danish National Socialist Workers Party, in August 1941, during World War II.

“I barely knew what it was, because I’ve never been interested in politics,” she said in an interview with Danish news outlet TV Midtvest two days after reaching her landmark age.

But newly uncovered documents in the Danish National Archives allegedly show Schwalbe was the acting leader of the party in her local town of Holstebro between August 1943 and July 1944, according to local reports. She also led the local women’s group.

Her late husband also reportedly held a leadership position in the Danish Nazi Party, which mimicked its German counterpart with the use of the swastika, the Hitler salute, and antisemitism, and actively collaborated with the Third Reich during the occupation of Denmark during the war.

“She was more than an ordinary member of the rank and file,” said Danish historian Claus Bundgaard Christensen, who examined the documents, describing Schwalbe as one of the “prominent Nazis” in her area at the time.

Schwalbe’s story came to light after the recent publication of a biography of her life, titled “We Need Something to Laugh About,” which made no mention of her Nazi past.

The Nazi revelations then emerged later last month in Danish newspaper Kristeligt Dagblad.

The report caught the biographer’s publisher, Gyldendal Publishing, and its authors, Frederik Helms and Line Morell Holm, by surprise, the publisher said, vowing further research and mentions in newer editions of the bio.

In previous interviews, Schwalbe bragged about her positive outlook aiding her long life.

“I don’t care that I’m going to die soon; I don’t think about it. I don’t often think about the future; I enjoy the good days and my good mood,” she told an interviewer on her 110th birthday, reported Bild.

Schwalbe’s family stated she is “deeply affected” by the recent media coverage and declined to comment further, while also requesting that her privacy be respected.

Time to Move to Beit Shemesh! As Sales Plunge!

 


New figures from Israel’s Central Bureau of Statistics show a sharp slowdown in the housing market in Bnei Brak and Beit Shemesh, with apartment sales in both cities down by more than 40% from a year ago, even as average prices in Beit Shemesh have overtaken those in Bnei Brak.

Data for the third quarter of 2026 put the average price of a 3.5 to 4-room apartment in Beit Shemesh at NIS 2,493,300, compared with NIS 2,428,200 in Bnei Brak, about NIS 65,000 more. A year earlier, a four-room apartment in Bnei Brak averaged NIS 2,697,500, while the same size in Beit Shemesh averaged NIS 2,358,800, leaving a family making the move with a gross difference of roughly NIS 339,000 before transaction costs.

Over the past year, average prices for apartments of that size fell about 10% in Bnei Brak and climbed about 5.7% in Beit Shemesh. For years, Chareidi families sold apartments in Bnei Brak or Yerushalayim, bought a bigger home in Beit Shemesh or Beitar Illit, and used the leftover money to help marry off their children. Today, a family selling a four-room apartment in Bnei Brak to buy a similar one in Beit Shemesh may not only lose that cushion but may have to add money.

In Bnei Brak, just 149 sales were counted in the bureau’s price calculation for the third quarter, down from 257 in the same quarter of 2025, a drop of about 42%. Beit Shemesh saw a similar slide, with sales falling from 481 to 283, a decline of about 41%. The drop in the two Chareidi cities was far steeper than the national decline of about 25%, and steeper than Yerushalayim’s drop of about 31%.

Despite the sharp fall in the number of deals, average prices across all apartments barely moved, slipping about 1.1% in Bnei Brak and about 0.4% in Beit Shemesh from a year earlier. The figures reflect averages of recorded sales used in the bureau’s price calculation, leave out government-subsidized deals, and are still preliminary for the latest quarter. The report also does not give a separate breakdown for Beitar Illit.

Eisenkott kicks Rav Landau and his political party UTJ to the curb they go scrambling back to Likud

 

A proposal by Gadi Eisenkot for a Chareidi draft outline has sparked anger in United Torah Judaism and set off a crisis in the talks between the two parties, with UTJ responding by lining up behind the Likud in a series of Knesset votes.

At a meeting earlier this week between Eisenkot and UTJ MK Yaakov Asher, the head of the Yashar party presented his plan for a draft outline that includes a temporary deferral of service for young Chareidi men alongside high enlistment targets.

UTJ was not impressed. Party officials said the outline was never even brought before the Litvish Gedolim for discussion, after it was deemed absurd and insulting.

In response, UTJ decided to send Eisenkot a public message and signal its opposition to the way the talks are being conducted. As part of that, the party’s MKs backed Likud MK Ofir Katz in the vote for Knesset Speaker, which MK Matan Kahana ultimately won.

The signal did not end there. In other votes held in the Knesset on Wednesday, UTJ’s MKs also joined the Likud and voted alongside it.

The developments highlight the difficulties Eisenkot faces in his effort to put together political partnerships, with the draft remaining one of the main points of dispute with the Chareidi parties.

Monsey Resident Mrs Shevy Frank Killed by train ....Wife of Reb Donny Frank

 



Mrs. Basheva Frank, a”h, 55, of New Hempstead, was killed Wednesday morning after a train collided with her vehicle at a railroad crossing on New Clarkstown Road in Nanuet.
Mrs. Frank A”H, the wife of Daniel Frank, was a beloved teacher at Rosenbaum Yeshiva of North Jersey (RYNJ).
The horrific incident occurred at approximately 8:00 a.m. According to information obtained by Monsey Scoop, traffic congestion had caused Mrs. Frank’s vehicle to become stopped on the railroad tracks. When the crossing gates began lowering, she exited her vehicle through the driver’s side. Tragically, the approaching train struck the passenger side of the vehicle, pushing the car into her and causing fatal injuries.
Multiple emergency agencies responded to the scene, where Mrs. Frank was Nifteres.
Misaskim, Chaverim of Rockland, and Chesed Shel Emes responded to the scene and ensured proper Kavod HaMes.
The heartbreaking tragedy has left the community mourning the sudden and devastating loss of Mrs. Frank a”h.
The levaya will take place Wednesday at 5:00 p.m. at Bais Hamedrish Kneses Yisroel, Rabbi Schabes’s Shul, located at 698 Union Road in New Hempstead.
Kevurah will take place in Eretz Yisroel.
Baruch Dayan HaEmes….