Outrage over Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s statement marking the third anniversary of the Oct. 7 Hamas attack continued to grow Wednesday, with thousands of people taking to social media to condemn the mayor’s remarks.The criticism, which began shortly after Mamdani released his statement, continued to spread throughout the day on X, drawing responses from elected officials, political figures, Jewish community advocates and others.
Mamdani acknowledged that Hamas killed more than 1,100 Israelis and abducted 251 people in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack, calling the day “profoundly painful.” But he also used his statement to criticize Israel’s military campaign in Gaza and accuse Israel of genocide.
Steven Fulop, the former mayor of Jersey City, said the anniversary should be focused on remembering the victims and standing with their families and survivors.
“The Mayor’s decision to use this solemn anniversary to advance divisive political arguments was inappropriate and unnecessarily inflammatory,” Fulop wrote on X. He said that as antisemitism remains a serious concern, New York’s elected leaders should be working to bring the city together rather than creating further division.
Rep. Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., called Mamdani’s statement “absolutely atrocious,” accusing the mayor of antisemitism and anti-Americanism.
“There is a reason both Democrats and Republicans are condemning this absolutely tone deaf and outrageous statement,” Stefanik wrote on X.
She said Oct. 7, 2023, was the bloodiest day for the Jewish people since the Holocaust and noted that innocent civilians, including Americans, were among those killed and attacked by Hamas.
Saritha Komatireddy, a former federal prosecutor and candidate for New York attorney general, also criticized Mamdani, saying he could have used the anniversary to honor those killed, raped, tortured and kidnapped by Hamas.
“Instead, he used their day of remembrance to attack Israel and accuse the Jewish state of genocide,” Komatireddy wrote.
She said Oct. 7 should be a day to remember the victims, condemn Hamas and stand with New York’s Jewish community.
Jamie Metzl, a liberal Democrat and human rights advocate, said Mamdani was increasingly positioning himself as an “enemy of the Jewish community of New York City.”
“It pains me to say this,” Metzl wrote, describing himself as a liberal Democrat, human rights advocate, New Yorker and human being. He accused Mamdani of repeatedly expressing what he characterized as bigotry.
Former U.S. Ambassador to Israel David Friedman also condemned the mayor’s statement, saying Mamdani had “defiled the memory” of innocent victims.
“October 7 was about Palestinian murderers and rapists and Jewish and non-Jewish civilian victims,” Friedman wrote. “There is no ‘other side’ to this story.”
Former Trump adviser and conservative commentator Mark Levin also attacked Mamdani, writing that the mayor “means what he says” and labeling him a “jihadist.”
Political commentator John Cardillo similarly called Mamdani a “terrorist enabler” in a post on X.
The criticism was not limited to Republicans and conservative voices.
Alex Vindman, a former U.S. Army officer and former Democratic congressional candidate, said Mamdani’s statement could hurt Democrats politically ahead of the midterm elections.
“Mayor Mamdani, normally an astute political actor, did a real disservice to DEMs and Dem DSA candidates immediately before midterm elections,” Vindman wrote. He said the mayor had “ignited controversy” at a time when Democrats were appealing to moderate and independent voters.
The growing backlash comes as New York marks the anniversary with vigils and memorial events honoring victims of the Hamas attack.
Mamdani’s supporters have defended his statement, arguing that it acknowledged the horror of Oct. 7 while also recognizing Palestinian suffering during the war that followed.
But critics say the mayor’s decision to include extensive criticism of Israel in his Oct. 7 statement was inappropriate and overshadowed the commemoration of the attack’s victims.
The reaction continued to intensify across X throughout Wednesday, with thousands of users posting comments, sharing Mamdani’s statement and criticizing the mayor’s handling of the anniversary.
The controversy has placed renewed attention on Mamdani’s relationship with New York’s Jewish community and his positions on Israel, Hamas and the war in Gaza as he marks his first Oct. 7 anniversary as mayor.