הרב רונן שאולוב מתנצל בפני חיילי צה״ל על השלט הבזוי ״עדיף היה למות בשואה מלמות במחנות צה״ל
“Rabbi Ronen Shaulov apologizes to IDF soldiers for the disgraceful sign that read: ‘It would have been better to die in the Holocaust than to die in IDF camps.’”
5 comments:
People say this all the time but it's just not possible.
Germany had millions of soldiers and the most modern and powerful military equipment. They had the assistance of millions of soldiers, milita and thugs across Europe. Exactly how would the Israeli army have been able to defeat that?
Garnel
I don't agree with you at all, it took the Germans a month to put down the Warsaw Uprising! When Jews fight back with even semi army they win
With the help of AI ...I got this, and it's all, of course, hypothetical
Short answer:
If the Jews of Europe had possessed a modern, organized, armed force even remotely comparable to the IDF, the Holocaust could not have unfolded the way it did.
But the deeper, more honest answer requires understanding why.
I’ll break it down clearly and without exaggeration.
1. The IDF is a modern national army. European Jews had nothing like it.
The IDF today has:
centralized command, trained officers, intelligence units
logistics, heavy weapons, air power, armor, supply chains,
European Jews in the 1930s–40s had:
no state,, no army, , no weapons, no training, no political sovereignty,
no borders to defend, no ability to mobilize, and they were scattered minorities under governments that often despised them.
The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising proves the point — and the limitation
You mentioned Warsaw.
It’s important to understand what actually happened:
Fewer than 1,000 fighters, Mostly pistols, homemade bombs, a handful of rifles, No supply lines, No reinforcements, No outside support, Starving, sick, trapped
And yet:They held off the German army for a month, Against tanks, artillery, flamethrowers, and thousands of soldiers
This is astonishing.
It shows what Jews could do with almost nothing.
Now imagine those same fighters with:
tanks, artillery, air support,, intelligence, coordinated command, trained officers, supply lines,, safe territory to retreat to and regroup,
That’s the IDF.
The Germans would not have been able to liquidate ghettos, deport millions, or run extermination camps if they faced a modern army.
. The Holocaust succeeded because Jews were stateless
This is the core truth.
The Nazis could murder six million Jews because Jews had no country
no borders,, no army, no diplomatic leverage,, no ability to flee en masse
no ability to resist in an organized way.
The Nazis could not have done this to:
the French,, the Poles, the British, the Russians,
Because those nations had armies.The Jews did not.
So would the IDF have stopped the Holocaust?
Yes — absolutely.
Not because Jews are superhuman, but because states with armies do not get exterminated.
The Nazis could invade Poland.They could invade France. They could invade the USSR.
But they could not exterminate the entire population of any of those countries.
Why?
Armies.
If the Jews had possessed even a small sovereign state with a functioning military, the Holocaust would have been impossible.
The IDF is the historical answer to “Never Again”
The IDF exists because of the Holocaust.
It is the institutionalized guarantee that Jews will never again be: stateless
defenseless, dependent on mercy, trapped behind borders, unable to fight back
The Warsaw fighters proved the Jewish will to resist.
The IDF provides the means.
Bottom line
If the Jews of Europe had the IDF, the Holocaust could not have happened.
Not even close.The Nazis could kill unarmed civilians.
They could not defeat a modern Jewish army.
Total Kefira! Hashem decided there would be a Holocaust (in no small part due to your Zionists and the havoc they wrought upon Klal Yisroel). No IDF would have changed the gzar DIN!
DIN, AI is the new prophet? C'mon you are not replaceable!!
Due to zionists??? You utter PoS. They hated jews...all Jews. No wonder moshiach won't come with dreks like you alive and spouting your pathetic weak-kneed hatreds. Go back to Romania you ferd
Post a Comment