 |
| Yaakov Shapiro the Menuval |
One of his central arguments — quoting the Satmar Rebbe — is that the Six‑Day War was not a miracle at all. According to this view, what looked like open miracles was actually the work of the “samech‑mem,” the devil, and the entire war was supposedly unnecessary, engineered by Zionists who wanted more territory.
Then comes the contradiction.
On one hand, he claims the Zionists won because they were “by far the strongest army in the Middle East.” On the other hand, he condemns the army for saying exactly that — accusing them of kochi v’otzem yadi.
You can’t have it both ways.
If the IDF was naturally stronger, then acknowledging that strength is not heresy — it’s honesty. If the victory was supernatural, then dismissing it as “the samech‑mem” is theological acrobatics.
And this is where the irony becomes impossible to ignore.
But anyone who remembers those days in 1967 knows that the entire Satmar premise is a delusionary fantasy, and the Zionist State was fighting a defensive war and had absolutely no intention of capturing any land except for the Golan Heights, and every word of the "Al Hagila" sounds like a spoiled child that didn't get his way!
In the video, Schapiro, calls Harav Hagoen Avraham Yitzchok Hakohein Kook z"l , a "Meshiginer Philosopher" ...This vile piece of scum is the voice of Satmar!
11 comments:
If something bad happens, it's God punishing us, it's because He loves us and is cleansing us from our sins.
If something good happens, it's the satan tempting us to think our sins are mitzvos so it's really bad.
What a sick philosophy. If it was true, I'd want nothing to do with Judaism.
You're wrong in your understanding of the problem with kochi veotzem yadi. The alternative is not that it was a supernatural neis. Its that what appears to be natural is actually G-d given. So his point is that what others say was a supernatural victory and a sign of divine favor was actually a natural victory which on its own isn't to be interpreted as a special sign. And additionally, the zionists took the credit for their success without attributing it to G-d.
The fact that he can say this in 2019 is bad enough. Hwever, just search YouTube clips. Since October 7th, he has dozens of clips where he is cavorting with our enemies and repeating the same nonsense, but this time he supports our enemies and is glad to do it. He also sits with Jewish kofrim who are anti. Zionist and sits as smiles with them because they are on the same page as to zionism. Really sickening
Rav Kasher in Hatekufa Hagedola discusses at length the constant saying that all the miracles are from the sitra achra. He says the entire idea of the sitra achra is only mentioned in the Zohar and yet it's the same Zohar that says there is no sitra achra in Eretz Yisrael!
12:40
I understand very well, YOU are the one who doesn't understand!
It was the Satmarer Rebbe who took G-D out of the equation and said that the victory of the IDF has nothing to do with the RBS"O and the victory was because the IDF is very strong!
In fact, in the book "AL Hagila" the rebbe doesn't mention Hashem's name at all in his rant!
So it's ok when the Satmer Rebbe says that the army has
כח ועצם but its "apikorsas" when the IDF says it!
We all get it!
In HaTekufah HaGedolah, Rav Kasher demolishes the Satmar shita once and for all. The only defense I ever heard was "Well of couse the Satmar is correct. He's the Satmar so anyone who disagrees must be wrong."
If you mean the Rav Kasher of Torah Shleima, he is a Chabadsker so he is looking to defend shitos of the Rebbe that lean Tzioni. Surely there has to be some smach somewhere for EY, otherwise there is no bechira for someone to resist SA and there are in any plenty of sins committed
Diddly Crap 9:41
Rav Menachem Kashe was not a Chabadsker, he was a Gerer Chasid! I know because I am related to him.
A "smach" somewhere for EY???
Ha ha LOL
Every chapter in the entire Tanach after Parshas Lech Lecha is all about EY!!
It's even in the Quran!
In this clip, you can see how Dovid Lichtenstein handled him so beautifully on Halacha Headlines. Dovid Lichtenstein said Shapiro would only agree to go on the show if Lichtenstein did not disagree with him!!! Hear how Dovid explains that that's not what his show is about. Its about Melchamto shel Torah. So what he did was just interview him in absentia, by just taking some of his youtube clips and dismembering him!
https://halachaheadlines.com/episodes/zionism-is-todays-zionism-the-same-movement-that-caused-so-many-religious-to-leave-their-roots-and-become-irreligious/?v=2b8741a3dcda
Did Rav Kasher remain a Gerrer? The purpose of Otwock yeshiva for instance was to poach Poilisher chassidim to transform them into Chabadskers. The crazed brainwashers were even attempting to proselytize in KJ. The Satmar chevra were drenching them with buckets of white paint to get them to skedaddle
Miss Ary
Rav Kasher z"L who is buried on Har Hamnuchot, was a Gerer Chusid until his dying day; in fact, he was a descendant of the Chiddushei Harim.
Post a Comment