by David Begoun
A lesson from Yad Vashem, a grandmother and a frog about the dangers we don’t recognize until it’s too late
By now, you probably know that I’m not a big fan of Holocaust museums. I’ve written before about my discomfort with the way Jewish history and identity can so often become defined by our suffering, our persecution, and the six million Jews who were murdered, rather than by our extraordinary contributions to civilization over thousands of years.
But Yad Vashem is different.
I’ve visited Jerusalem’s Holocaust museum more times than I can count, often as a tour guide, and somehow I always come away having learned something new. Sometimes it’s a story, sometimes a photograph, sometimes a detail about the Holocaust that I hadn’t appreciated before. And recently, while guiding a group through the museum, I shared something I’d only recently learned about the building itself, something that has been on my mind ever since.
The Next Room
Yad Vashem’s Holocaust History Museum was designed by the internationally renowned Israeli architect Moshe Safdie. It’s an extraordinary structure, a long triangular prism cutting straight through the mountainside, with natural light pouring in from above.
What really fascinates me is the way Safdie designed the galleries.
As you walk through the museum, you’re forced to move from one gallery to another, following the chronological progression of the Holocaust. The galleries are deliberately concealed from view until you reach them. You cannot simply look ahead and see where the story is going.
And I think that’s absolutely brilliant.
Because one of the questions people invariably ask me when I’m guiding them through Yad Vashem is: Why didn’t the Jews leave when things started getting bad?
Why didn’t they get out of Germany when Hitler came to power? Why didn’t they recognize the danger when the Nazis began passing anti-Jewish laws? Why did so many remain as the situation grew progressively worse, until eventually it was too late?
It’s a perfectly understandable question. Standing in the museum today, knowing what we know, it seems almost inconceivable that anyone would have stayed. And that’s precisely the question Safdie’s architecture is designed to help answer.
By preventing us from seeing the next gallery, Safdie places us, at least for a moment, in the position of the people who actually lived through those years. They couldn’t see what was coming next either. They had no idea how much worse it would get or what horrors awaited them around the corner.
Today, we walk into Yad Vashem knowing how the story ends. We know about the ghettos and the cattle cars, about Auschwitz and Treblinka, and the gas chambers and the crematoria.
But imagine being a Jew living in Berlin in 1933.
Hitler has just come to power. There are ugly speeches, hateful posters, boycotts of Jewish businesses. Jewish civil servants are losing their jobs. It’s frightening, certainly. But this is Germany. Your country. Your home. The place where your parents and grandparents lived, where you built your business, raised your children, and made your life.
Surely this madness won’t last. Surely this is as bad as it will get.
Then come the Nuremberg Laws in 1935, stripping Jews of their citizenship rights. More restrictions. More humiliations. More reasons to worry. But life goes on. People still get married, children go to school, and families still gather around the Shabbat table. Perhaps things will improve after the next election, the next change in government, the next international crisis.
And then comes November 1938. Kristallnacht. Synagogues are burned, Jewish businesses are smashed, and thousands of Jewish men are arrested and sent to concentration camps.
Suddenly, the danger is impossible to ignore.
But now, leaving is no simple matter. Where do you go? Who will take you? How do you get a visa? What happens to your business, your home, your elderly parents?
Many German Jews understood the danger and desperately tried to escape. Hundreds of thousands succeeded. Others found the doors of the world closing in their faces. And then, in 1939, war breaks out. Soon, for many, the opportunity to escape is gone altogether.
That’s the terrible genius of Safdie’s architecture. It helps answer the question that seems so obvious to us today, but was anything but obvious to those living through it.
Because when you’re standing in one room, you cannot see the next.
The Boiling Frog
There’s an old story about a frog placed in a pot of water.
Drop the frog into boiling water, the story goes, and it will immediately jump out. But place it in cool water and gradually raise the temperature, and the frog will become accustomed to the increasing heat. By the time it realizes what’s happening, it’s too late.
Now, before the marine biologists among you start sending me angry emails, let me acknowledge that the famous boiling frog experiment is more folklore than science. Real frogs generally have enough sense to try to escape dangerously hot water.
But as a metaphor for human behavior, it’s remarkably effective.
We have an extraordinary ability to adjust to changing circumstances, even unpleasant ones. Yesterday’s outrage becomes tomorrow’s ordinary reality. Something that would have shocked us five years ago barely raises an eyebrow today.
Psychologists and social scientists have names for related phenomena: habituation, shifting baselines, and normalization of deviance. The common thread is that gradual changes can be difficult to appreciate when we’re living through them.
And that’s what makes the question we so often ask about the Holocaust so terribly unfair: Why didn’t the Jews just leave?
We know what happened next. They didn’t.
They were making decisions with the information available to them at the time, weighing the dangers they could see against the enormous costs of abandoning everything they knew.
History is remarkably easy to understand when you’re looking backward. It’s a whole lot harder when you’re living through it.
What’s Happening in America?
I’ve been thinking about all of this as I watch the changing political landscape in the United States, particularly the rise of the Democratic Socialists of America and the growing popularity of politicians like Zohran Mamdani in New York and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan.
What troubles me isn’t simply the politicians themselves. It’s the enthusiasm with which so many young Americans are embracing them, and especially their increasingly hostile attitudes toward Israel and Zionism. Ideas that would have been considered extreme just a few years ago are now being cheered at political rallies, repeated on college campuses, and enthusiastically shared across social media.
And I can’t help wondering whether we’re becoming just like our friend the frog, sitting in the water as the temperature slowly rises.
For generations, American Jews have enjoyed a degree of freedom, security, and acceptance that our ancestors in Europe could scarcely have imagined. During my childhood, America was a place where Jews could build extraordinary communities, practice their religion openly, and participate fully in society. And for the most part, we’ve taken that security for granted.
But something feels different today.
The hostility toward Israel that exploded after October 7 has, in some places, spilled over into hostility toward Jews themselves. Jewish students have found themselves intimidated on college campuses. Jewish institutions require increasing security. And political rhetoric that would once have been considered beyond the pale is becoming increasingly acceptable, particularly among younger Americans.
Of course, criticizing Israel is not antisemitic, and supporting Palestinian rights does not make someone an enemy of the Jewish people. But there are moments when the distinction between opposition to Israeli policies and hostility toward Jews seems to be growing dangerously thin.
And perhaps what troubles me most is how quickly we’re becoming accustomed to it all. Something happens that would have shocked us five years ago. We’re outraged. We talk about it. And then, a few weeks later, something else happens, and the previous outrage begins to feel almost normal.
The water gets a little warmer.
I am certainly not suggesting that America in 2026 is Germany in 1933. The differences are enormous, and comparisons that ignore them do a disservice to history. But I do find myself wondering how we recognize the moment when a series of troubling developments becomes something more serious.
And how do we know whether we’re overreacting to the heat or simply getting used to it?
Which brings me to a conversation I had recently.
A Bubby’s Warning
Not long ago, I met an American Jewish couple who told me they were making aliyah, the Hebrew term for moving to Israel.
I asked them why.
As a tour guide in Israel, I meet people all the time who are considering making Israel their home. Some have dreamed of living here since childhood. Others want their children to grow up speaking Hebrew, celebrating Jewish holidays in the streets, or being part of the extraordinary story of the Jewish people returning to their homeland.
But this couple surprised me. They told me they didn’t particularly want to leave America. They had a good life there. They were comfortable. They weren’t running toward some long-cherished dream of living in Israel.
So why were they coming?
“My bubby was a Holocaust survivor,” one of them told me. “And she always told me that when things start to get bad in America for the Jews, that’s when it’s time to leave, because they won’t get better.”
I don’t know whether their grandmother’s warning will prove prophetic. I sincerely hope it won’t. America is still home to a vibrant Jewish community with remarkable institutions, political freedoms, and the ability to defend its interests.
But I keep thinking about that grandmother. She survived the Holocaust, and I imagine she spent the rest of her life wondering whether she and her family could have recognized the danger sooner. And now, all these years later, her granddaughter was taking that warning seriously enough to pack up her life in America and move to Israel.
Her bubby was teaching us all a lesson about the limits of our ability to recognize danger while we’re living through it.
The View of Jerusalem
Let’s not end this on a dark note. There’s one final architectural detail about Yad Vashem that I love.
After walking through the eerie galleries, after experiencing the destruction of European Jewry, you emerge from the mountain into the sunlight. And suddenly, spread out before you, is Jerusalem.
It’s an extraordinary moment.
After everything you’ve just seen, after the unimaginable suffering and destruction, there is the Jewish capital, alive and flourishing. The hills of Jerusalem, the buildings, the trees, the sounds of a country that didn’t exist when the Holocaust began.
Safdie designed that moment deliberately. And every time I stand there with a group, I capitalize on the gift he gave us.
Because whatever lessons we draw from Jewish history, one thing has fundamentally changed. Today, Jews have somewhere to go. We have a country of our own. A place where Jewish sovereignty is a reality, where Jews can defend themselves, and where Jews from anywhere in the world can come home.
That doesn’t mean every Jew should leave America. It doesn’t mean the fears of that couple are necessarily justified. And it certainly doesn’t mean that history is destined to repeat itself. But it does mean that Jews today have a choice that millions of our ancestors never had.
I think about that couple, reluctantly packing up their lives in America, listening to the voice of a grandmother who survived the Holocaust. I think about the countless Jewish families in Europe who wrestled with impossible decisions, never knowing what tomorrow would bring.
And I think about those galleries at Yad Vashem, each one revealing a chapter of history that the people living through the previous chapter could never have imagined.
We know what’s in the next room at Yad Vashem, but in real life, we never do.

No comments:
Post a Comment