Page 58 of Tractate Menachos was already discussed yesterday.
I will attempt, depending on my time constraints to cover 7 pages (dafim) every week.
You can copy and print this without my consent, since Torah belongs to all of us.....
דף נ''ט .. שמן על המנחה
Page 59 Mesectas Menachois
"Oil with the Korban Mincha"
The Talmud talks about the Mincha sacrifice that was brought to the Temple by someone who sinned or violated a Biblical ordinance by mistake.
*Note: Sacrifices were brought only by those who mistakingly sinned ... there are no sacrifices for those who sinned or violated a Biblical ordinance on purpose.
The Talmud explains that there cannot be any oil accompanying a Mincha, that someone brought because he sinned. It therefore follows, that the Kohein cannot add oil to the Mincha , even if he wishes to do so.
Why?
Because Minchas in general, are supposed to be elegant and the Torah didn't want that the Mincha of a sinner (even if the sin was done inadvertently) to be elegant.
What would be the halacha if the Kohein poured a drop of oil on this particular Mincha sacrifice?
According what we learn on this daf, the entire Mincha sacrifice would be rendered invalid.
Therefore even one drop of oil would invalidate the entire Mincha, because the Torah stated emphatically on a sinner's Mincha ...... ''לא ישים עליה שמן'' .... "Do not place [on the mincha] oil"
But there can be a situation where oil placed on a sinner's mincha would still be valid ....
and that is, if the oil was placed on a piece of the Mincha that didn't have the required size ... the required size for the Mincha to still be valid would be the size of an olive.
Press "read more" below, to continue to the rest of the dafim!
Press "read more" below, to continue to the rest of the dafim!











