MU writes that
"All our Gedoilim post WW2 opposed and strongly held not to celebrate or say Hallel on this day"
I am not going into whether we should say Hallel on Yom Ha'Atzmaut or not, but his statement is an unmitigated lie!
The following are just some Rabbanim that said Hallel:
Rabbi Meshulam Roth (Shu"t Kol Mevaser) — one of the earliest poskim to rule for Hallel with a beracha after 1948.
Rabbi Yehuda Gershuni — ruled similarly to Rav Roth.
Rabbi Shaul Yisraeli — supported Hallel with a beracha.
Rabbi Ovadia Yosef — supported Hallel without a beracha (a more cautious but still affirmative ruling).
Rabbi Herzog, Rabbi Unterman, Rav Yehuda Kook,
Below is a photo of Gedoilei Yisrael saying Hallel and celebrating Yom Ha"atzmaut
| Seen in this photo the Sadiger Rebbe, Harav Shatzroviski, the Rebbe of Boyhush |
Then as an aside, he throws in:
"True the Ponivetcher Rav did put out an Israeli flag on the Yeshiva dormitory, for other reasons"
First of all it wasn't on the dormitory that he put the flag on, it was on the Bais Medrish itself that Rav Kahanaman instructed that they put an Israeli flag!
Second of all, what WERE the "other reasons?"
Everyone knows the reason, the reason was to give Hakoras Hatoiv to the Medina! Why can't he just say it?
Then he says that
"the Chazon Ish, Brisker Rav, Rav Moshe Feinstein and Tshebiner Rav, were against it"
So here we have a guy that calls himself "MU," lives in the USA and does not at all listen to any of their rulings, he chose to name these Gedoilim only to bash the only Jewish State in the world!
Let's first deal with the Chazon Ish who lived in Eretz Yisrael. He paskened lehalacha that living in Eretz Yisrael is a biblical mitzva according to the Rambam and the Ramban and that this is a obligation in the here and now!
ומצות ארץ ישראל הוכרעה על ידי הרמב"ם והרמב"ן ושאר פוסקים, וידוע עד כמה שאף החפץ חיים זללה"ה לעלות
הרצון שתיהיה ארץ ישראל מיושבת מישראל, והרי אנו חייבים בישובה ודור בה גם בגלותנו וכמו שהא הר"מ פרק ה מהלכות מלכים (קובץ אגרות חזון איש ..ומכתב קעה)
MU doesn't really care about the Chazon Ish's pask that one must live in Eretz Yisrael, because we see that he lives comfortably in Flatbush, and sees nothing in the irony of him lecturing us that that the Chazon Ish was against saying Hallel!! He picks and chooses which CI suits his anti-Israel agenda!
The Brisker Rav also lived in Eretz Yisrael and was a vehement proponent of Yishuv Eretz Yisrael and held that once someone even comes to Eretz Yisrael, he cannot leave, in fact Briskers never leave Eretz Yisrael. MU chooses to highlight a political view of the Brisker Rav who opposed the State, but lived there nevertheless and advocated for those in Galuth to move to Israel! Again MU names a Gadol only for his hateful agenda!
Rav Moshe Feinstein, also holds that Yishuv E"Y is a mitzva min HaTorah
ובדבר שאלתך אם יש מצוה עכשיו לדור בארץ ישראל כהרמב"ן או כהרבינו חיים בתוספות כתובות קי. אי דאינה מצוה בזמן הזה. הנה רוב הפוסקים סברי דהוא מצוה
שבודאי יש מצוה (שו"ת אגרות משה חלק יו"ד ג סימן קכב)
Tshebiner Rav also lived in Eretz Yisrael, and acknowledged the state as a reality, he was a strong advocate for every Jew to live in Israel.
Then this MU guy, tells a story about the Chazon Ish about a guy who stopped saying Tikkun Chazos after the State was established, "I cannot understand, is this what he was waiting for, a country that has intentions to be oiker Torah? " I don't know if this story is even true, because if you read the Steipler's 5 Volume Bio, he states that 99% of all Chazon Ish stories were made up!
It turns out that in retrospect, if the story is true, that the Chazon Ish's prediction did not come to fruition as the Zionist State is now the largest makom Torah in the entire world, and the Zionist Government is the largest contributor to Torah in history!
Then he quotes Rav Elchonon Wasserman hy"d which every Yeshivishe Shoiteh quotes, to denigrate the founders of the only Jewish State and who built a home for ALL Jews, לשם ולתפארת! Rav Elchonon was in the USA when WW2 broke out and didn't want to leave his students alone in Europe and so he returned and was murdered. If there was a State then, Rav Elchonon and his Talmidim would have survived!
But he doesn't follow Rav Elchonon either.
This is what Rav Elchonon wrote in his Sefer קובץ מאמרי עקבתא דמשיחא
( ישיבת אור אלחנן תשס"ב עמוד קמה)
ארץ ישראל תופסת מקום עיקרי בתורה. שלשה סדרים בש"ס קשורים בארץ ישראל.... חלק גדול של שלשה הסדרים הנשארים אף הוא קשור בארץ ישראל
כמעט שני שלישי הש"ס תלויים בארץ ישראל אותו יחס מספרי גם בחומש. מובן על כן כי ארץ ישראל היא צורך חיוני לישראל
מלבד זה, הרי ישוב ארץ ישראל הוא מצוה בפני עצמה
MU lives in luxury in the USA, quotes Gedoilim that he doesn't listen to, but he lectures us!
MU totally takes out the Ribono Shel Olilim out of the equation of the establishment of the State! He doesn't think that the RBS"O had anything to do with it!
He states that Torah grew in the State "despite the State" and that the "ruchniyois is very weak in Israel"
What a bald-faced liar!
"Ruchniyois is very weak in Israel?" Mamesh Loshon Hara not only on the Land but on it residents!
What is this "mereigel" even talking about? There are more Moisdois Hatorah in the Zionist State of Israel than any other place on earth! I'll bet that this MU tzaddik probably hangs out on the beach when he visits Israel!
All these Yeshivishe morons say that Torah grew "despite" the State!
No it didn't!
Who supports ALL Torah institutions making it possible for all these Kollilim? The Zionists!
Just 3 months ago, the State gave 800 million Shekel to Torah institutions!
It's not "despite" ...The Zionists are the largest contributors to torah in Jewish history!
I don't know who this MU shoiteh is, but it's important to point out, that this is the crap that is being fed to our children in our moisdois.
They cannot get over that the State is here to stay until "bee'as ha'Moshiach" it's vibrant, it's from the 5 best economies in the world, has the best army, and the people are from the top 8 of the happiest in the world, despite being in a war. Real estate prices is through the roof, with people falling over themselves to buy property so they will have a place when they come rounding them up!
The fight that the "gedoilim" had with Zionists was over 75 years ago! No one has ever been stopped from learning Torah in the State, these are all lies that have been proven wrong over and over, but they need to keep this "Zionist is bad" thing going on so they can stay in Chutz Leaaretz!
It won't be too long when they all come running to the Zionist State! Even Satmar is looking to build a yishuv in the North!


