“I don’t speak because I have the power to speak; I speak because I don’t have the power to remain silent.” Rav Kook z"l

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Kalover Rebbe Urges French Jews Not To Rush Into Moving To Eretz Yisroel Out Of Fear .....When did we hear this before?

 

What was the saying they attributed to Albert Einstein?

"Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results."

How does a spiritual leader not learn his own history? How does a Rav give such terrible advice to a besieged community? Even a blind man can see what is happening in France? 
This is exactly the advice that European Rabbanim gave their communities pre WW2 and in retrospect we see how wrong they were! 

The Rebbe based this on what he saw from people that did make Aliyah.

"He explained that complaints have reached him from many families who moved without proper research and without asking daas Torah, only to lose their parnassah, while their children ended up in mixed schools for boys and girls and declined both spiritually and materially, rachmana litzlan."

With all due respect to the Kaliver Rebbe, the facts on the ground gives an entirely different story. I live in Beit Shemesh in midst of a large French Community and not one of the families' children "ended up in mixed schools for boys and girls".

No one "ended up" that is a lie. Yes, if the parents choose co-ed schools, then of course they will "end up" in mixed schools... Not one French child "ended up" anywhere without being placed there by parents themselves.
As far as "parnassa" goes, that comes from the RBS"O but this rebbe obviously doesn't believe that! 


The Kalover Rebbe, Hagaon HaRav Menachem Mendel Taub, has sent a special letter of chizuk to the Jews of France amid the unrest gripping the country, warning them not to make a hasty decision to move to Eretz Yisroel out of fear without first seeking daas Torah.

The letter was sent through the Rebbe’s son, Hagaon HaRav Yissachar Dov Taub, av beis din of the Kalov kehillah in Williamsburg, who spent the past month on his annual chizuk trip to France on his father’s behalf. During the visit he delivered drashos and received the public in kehillos and mosdos across the country, as thousands of French Jews came to receive brachos and seek advice. The trip took place as violent protests spread through French cities and Jewish property was damaged in several places, prompting many to tell Hagaon HaRav Yissachar Dov Taub that they were considering leaving France.

“First of all, be careful not to decide to move to Eretz Yisroel in a panic because of fear, but think it over very, very carefully beforehand,” the Rebbe wrote. He explained that complaints have reached him from many families who moved without proper research and without asking daas Torah, only to lose their parnassah, while their children ended up in mixed schools for boys and girls and declined both spiritually and materially, rachmana litzlan.

“However, the main advice for being saved from bad occurrences, both in France and in Eretz Yisroel, is to strengthen ourselves in keeping Torah and mitzvos, and to send all the boys and girls only to Torah institutions that have separate places for boys and girls, and to strengthen these institutions,” the Rebbe continued. He concluded that Hashem is watching over them and everything depends on Him, and that in the merit of the Torah, which protects and saves everywhere, Hashem will grant them good tidings.

The letter has been translated into French and is being distributed by askanim, primarily to a list of nearly 80,000 French Jews who have formed personal ties with the Kalover Rebbe during his many chizuk visits to France over the past 30 years, and who remain in contact through the Rebbe’s Ohr Olam kiruv organization.

11 comments:

Garnel Ironheart said...

It's worse than stupid. It's wicked. We still have Holocaust survivors who could tell you how the rabbonim told them to stay put and everything will be all right but here he is again giving the same advice.

Think before you criticize said...

So it never dawned on you that while there might not be a problem in Beit Shemesh there are other places where bad things happened? It’s smart advice for the Rebbe to warn to make sure where they’re going is safe instead of getting out of Dodge in a rushed stampede to who knows where

Dusiznies said...

4:19
The rebbe is being very disingenuous, to put it mildly. Those Frenchman whose children "ended up" in co-ed schools made a decision about where they wanted to live, and it was obviously NOT in Charedie areas; they CHOSE to live there and put their children in co-ed schools!
All the Frenchman in my neighborhoods told me that they ALL chose and were familiar with the neighborhoods. France is not too far from Israel, most Frenchman travel to Israel all the time to tour, to go on vacation and do business here, they know in advance where they would live.
They rebbe is either very naive or is deliberately lying!

Anonymous said...

And we still have Yemenites around who rushed out of Yemen hoping for a better future in Israel and who had their Yiddishkeit ripped away from them...

Dusiznies said...

6:55
Are you suggesting that the French Jews remain in France until they are murdered on the streets?
The Yemenite story happened 75 to 80 years ago, it is now 2026 and there are more frum Jews in the Zionist State than anywhere in the entire world, including Fakewood! There are more moisdois ha"torah in the Zionist state than anywhere in the world!
The chances of a Jew assimilating in Chutz Leaartz is over 85%!
Those Jews in France have a 85% chance of having goyim as grandchildren, whereas in Israel the chances are less than 2%
The Kaliver Rebbe should stick to singing lullabies and stop giving bad advice to Jews in France; blood will be on his fancy bekashe if anything happens!

Anonymous said...

It's a reflection that our leaders are puffed up Popes, high on prestige and status without any real wisdom.

Rolled-Up-Eyes said...

Ostrich who want people to live in fear for their lives. I had such respect for the Alter Rebbe. He really knew the consequences of staying put if anyone did.
The rest of Europe and the UK is 15 years behind France.

Anonymous said...

6:55
How sick and depraved are you? You deranged dog!
Bringing up a story about Yemenites from over 70 years ago to the dangerous circumstances taking place now in France.
How low will a person go?
Is this what your rabbaim embedded in your contaminated heart, to hate the Zionists with such passion as to connect everything to ancient stories?
DIN is spot on and has you guys pegged!

Anonymous said...

Is anyone forcing anyone else to follow this particular rebbe?

If not, why can't he express his opinion without all the braying?

YSV the Root of All Evil said...

DIN will tell you I told you so for the Golus & in this case he is right! A French mishpocho came to Monsey when that Achzar Yudi Frankel was still there. Of their 2 kids only 1 was accepted to YSV despite that the other had nowhere to go & YSV has lots of unused space. The mother came every day to cry a river to Frankel. One day he turned to her with his iced over eyes to threaten her if you come again to cry I will remove your kid who lucked out. She had to put the 2nd kid in co-ed school which ended the kid's frumkeit in a year or less. I verified this story with a Chassidishe Rebbe who calls Frankel Mr. Eitz vuEven vus iz usid litein es Hadin.

Dusiznies said...

2:01
You don't belong on this blog, you don't get the entire situation.