I write in response to Monday’s incident in Beit Shemesh involving police violence against Charedi protesters, as well as the subsequent investigation. While I unequivocally condemn any form of police brutality, I believe it’s important to understand the context of the event being protested and the community dynamics at play.
The protesters were not rallying against some harmful policy or oppressive regime—they were protesting an event designed to help young Charedi men acquire valuable skills for the workforce. The programs highlighted at the event offered education in areas like programming, bookkeeping, engineering, and healthcare—honest professions that enable individuals to support their families with dignity. These protesters are ideologically opposed to any form of secular studies, even if it means blocking others in their community from gaining skills that lead to upstanding, respectable jobs.
Imagine for a moment that members of the Brooklyn or Lakewood communities harassed others who had jobs. Imagine if they tormented individuals who took it upon themselves to earn an income for their families. You wouldn’t stand for that, would you? And yet, when it happens here, your focus is on how the police responded to these miscreants, but you say nothing about the damage these extremists are causing.
As a local resident, I’ve witnessed firsthand the damage caused by them, who are a small but vocal minority. Many of us in the community, including Charedim such as myself, are deeply frustrated with their disruptive tactics and aggressive behavior. They shout insults, create unnecessary chaos, and degrade anyone who does not align with their narrow viewpoint. Their actions are a source of fear and discomfort for families trying to live in peace, and their behavior reflects poorly on the broader community.
It’s important to note that the majority of Charedim in Beit Shemesh do not support these protests. In fact, many religious men attended the event to better themselves and their families through education, distancing themselves from the protestors and demonstrating their commitment to Torah values like Ahavas Yisrael and peaceful coexistence.
We need to foster dialogue and understanding, not perpetuate sinas chinam. Our community is diverse, with Jews from across the spectrum striving to live together in harmony. The protesters represent a distortion of values that harms us all. I hope they realize that there are many paths to serving Hashem, and that unity, not division, is what will bring Mashiach closer.
Sincerely,
Upset in RBS
The video of the police beating the chareidi bochrim was on Linkdin a business forum, these chareidi business guys were commenting how the police are Nazis, the police brutality was uncalled for etc etc, I commented that Israel has two parts Israel and Eretz Yisroel, those bochrim should not be demonstrating against anything they should be learning davening etc, even though there are many issues that Israel has that we don’t agree with but they protect Eretz Yisroel, some would claim that it’s because of Israel the Arabs want to kill the Jews doesn’t wash.
ReplyDeleteThe bochrim cause a massive Chilul Hashem and Cause sinas chinom and for this comment I was blocked by couple of chareidi people
Nefesh bnefesh does not advertise this to those they hope to convince to make aliya
ReplyDeleteOne cannot foster dialogue with fanatics. One can only convince them with a crowbar to the head.
ReplyDelete4:30
ReplyDeleteNefesh B'nefesh also doesn't write about Jews in Chutz Le'aaretz who are being beaten half to death!